Nintendo Slips To 22nd In Metacritic’s 2024 Publisher Rankings

17 March 2025
General
14 min.
WhatsAppMessengerLinkedInRedditPinterestBufferSMS
Nintendo Slips To 22nd In Metacritic’s 2024 Publisher Rankings

Summary:

Nintendo’s performance in Metacritic’s 15th annual publisher rankings took many by surprise this year. Landing at 22nd out of 37 publishers, Nintendo garnered an average Metascore of 76 across 13 releases—still within a “Generally Favorable” range, yet lower than its usual placement. By contrast, SEGA climbed to the very top with an 82.9 average, edging out fierce competitors like Capcom, Microsoft, and Sony. This development highlights how Nintendo’s 2024 lineup, though not devoid of noteworthy hits such as the remake of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, Super Mario Party, and The Legend Of Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom, lacked the overall volume and standout entries needed to secure a higher rank. Although fans recognize Nintendo for its quality franchises, Metacritic’s system places weight on critical reception, emphasizing both innovation and consistency. SEGA’s remarkable comeback underscores the importance of delivering fresh experiences that captivate reviewers and gamers alike. With growing anticipation for upcoming titles and continued enthusiasm among fans, Nintendo may yet reclaim a stronger footing in future rankings. The bigger question is whether the company will transform these insights into more engaging releases that once again see them rise on the charts. This year’s results may simply be a stepping stone for greater things ahead.

Understanding This Year’s Rankings

Metacritic’s 15th annual game publisher rankings have been the talk of the gaming community, and it’s not hard to see why. Each year, publishers’ average critic review scores are tallied up to create a hierarchical listing of who had the most impactful releases. Fans and industry insiders watch these rankings like spectators at a grand sports event, eager to see if their favorite companies will rise, fall, or perhaps hold steady. This year’s results might seem like a rollercoaster for those who follow Nintendo. While the company has historically performed well, 2024 marked a distinctive shift. Some say it’s because tastes are changing, while others point to the possibility that Nintendo’s core franchises didn’t see as many blockbuster entries. An annual ranking can sometimes feel like an awards ceremony—complete with unexpected wins, snubs, and controversies. Behind those flashy numbers lies a complex dynamic. Metacritic aggregates review scores from various professional critics, assigning a Metascore based on a weighted average. It’s not just about sales or fan hype; it’s a reflection of how the media perceives each title’s quality, innovation, and execution. When placed in the broader context of a year’s worth of releases, it offers a snapshot of how a publisher performed in critical eyes. Naturally, whenever lists like these come out, fans dive into debates about whether Metacritic’s scores are too harsh or too lenient. Some argue critics don’t always capture the spirit of a game, while others claim these assessments are vital for guiding purchasing decisions. Regardless, these rankings have become a widespread reference point, with 2024’s edition standing out for its unexpected twists and turns. In the midst of all this buzz, a closer look at Nintendo’s spot and how it compares to other publishers can reveal deeper insights. Sometimes, a single year’s outcome can act as a telling indicator of evolving gaming trends. Will the publishers who surged upward continue their momentum? And for those who dipped, like Nintendo, will they bounce back stronger? As we unfold this story, keep an open mind about how creative decisions, strategic planning, and plain old luck can shape the final scores. We’ve seen year-over-year swings before, and we’ll certainly see them again in the future of this ever-evolving industry.

Nintendo’s Position

Nintendo’s average Metascore of 76 left them at 22nd, a result that some might describe as humbling. Yet, it’s important to note that anything above 75 on Metacritic is typically viewed as “Generally Favorable.” So, while it’s not a glittering endorsement of top-tier performance, it still indicates decent critical reception. The intriguing part is that Nintendo has rarely been so far down the list in years past, which raises questions about what exactly happened in 2024. Critics of the ranking process may point out the difference between “number of releases” and “quality of releases.” Nintendo launched 13 games during this period, including some well-known franchises, but the consistent high scores usually anchored by flagship titles just weren’t as prevalent. A couple of games landed squarely in good territory, but critics may have wanted to see more innovative or revolutionary offerings that could redefine the gaming experience. Some fans suggest that 2024 was a transitional year for Nintendo, potentially focusing on future hardware or next-gen development. The logic goes that significant resources might have shifted away from producing multiple high-profile titles and into behind-the-scenes projects. Whether or not this theory holds water, the absence of a massive blockbuster akin to a new 3D Mario or a revolutionary Zelda undoubtedly played a role in the final ranking. Though 22nd may seem disconcerting, perspective is crucial. This rating is not a universal condemnation. Instead, it’s a snapshot in time reflecting how critics weighed Nintendo’s releases against the competition. One quieter year doesn’t negate a legacy of strong franchises that have shaped the industry for decades. Besides, rankings have a way of galvanizing companies to innovate further. Sometimes being lower on a list can be the jolt needed to experiment with new ideas, resurrect dormant series, or collaborate with external studios. Nintendo has a track record of bouncing back, so it’s reasonable to imagine new surprises could be in store.

Review Scores And Their Impact

When it comes to these reviews, the impact goes beyond a fleeting headline. Critics’ opinions can affect purchase decisions, online discussions, and even the direction of future projects. In an era where a single tweet can spark or douse excitement, Metascores have become a handy gauge for mainstream audiences. For Nintendo, there’s always been a reputation for charm and quality, so a dip in scores often ignites passionate debates about what might be missing or underperformed. The reality is that critics have diverse perspectives, and no rating system can perfectly capture everyone’s experience. That said, seeing a major publisher like Nintendo slip in the rankings can serve as an alert that maybe the year’s releases, though far from bad, didn’t ignite that spark of universal acclaim. It’s a reminder that, even for the giants of gaming, nothing is guaranteed. This might not be the story fans were hoping to hear, but constructive feedback can fuel better titles down the road. And when Nintendo does bounce back—and history suggests they will—the heightened anticipation can make those next announcements feel even more exhilarating.

Standout Titles Of 2024

You might be wondering, “If Nintendo landed at 22nd, does that mean none of their releases were noteworthy?” Far from it. Critics and fans found plenty to love in certain titles. The year wasn’t a total wash; rather, it lacked the volume of high-performing hits that elevate an entire slate of releases. With a few titles hovering around the mid-to-high 70s and a couple creeping into the 80s range, Nintendo still showcased its enduring flair for creative gameplay. Remarkably, the lineup included fresh content and revivals of older classics, each aiming to resonate with both new gamers and longtime enthusiasts. Although not every game made waves, several secured a dedicated following, reminding everyone that Nintendo’s charm often lies in its ability to tap into nostalgia. Gamers also noted that some projects felt like stepping stones. Early glimpses of innovative mechanics or new directions hinted that Nintendo could be testing the waters for bigger reveals in the future. If the critics’ feedback encourages more refinement and ingenuity, then the seeds planted in 2024 may blossom in the years to come.

Paper Mario’s Comeback

Among the year’s surprises, the remake of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door stood out. Returning to its distinctive paper-based world thrilled fans who adored the original release. Critics praised its faithful enhancements, improved visuals, and tweaks that offered both nostalgia and novelty. The self-aware humor, witty dialogue, and lighthearted RPG mechanics reignited interest in Nintendo’s spinoff Mario adventures. If there was any downside, it might be that the remake didn’t revolutionize the genre in the same way as the original had once done. Still, when judged on its own merits, it proved to be a highlight. Some players mentioned they would have loved to see more robust additions, like entirely new story segments or extended areas. Nonetheless, it did enough to please dedicated fans and curious newcomers alike.

The Thousand-Year Door Remake’s Legacy

This remake of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door carried the burden of living up to its original era, a time when such creative risks felt groundbreaking. In 2024, a remake risks being dismissed as a quick nostalgia grab. Yet, critics generally agreed it retained the series’ whimsical charm without feeling stale. That’s a tightrope walk—one that indicates Nintendo is still eager to honor classic formulas while preserving the sense of wonder that made them special in the first place. From a historical perspective, The Thousand-Year Door cemented Paper Mario’s place as an ingenious twist on the usual Mario storyline, blending familiar characters with tongue-in-cheek writing. In 2024, the remake served as both a reminder of how far the industry has come and a cautionary tale about how easily beloved series can slip off the radar if not handled carefully. This delicate balance of homage and modernization speaks volumes about Nintendo’s respect for its own legacy and its fans’ nostalgia.

Quiet Year For Nintendo?

Many have described 2024 as a “quiet” year for the company, pointing to the comparatively lower number of major new IPs or boundary-pushing titles. But is quiet always a bad thing? Sometimes, a strategic lull can help developers focus on polishing future projects, ensuring that when the next wave of games arrives, it does so with maximum impact. A year spent gathering feedback, perfecting engines, and rethinking older concepts can pay dividends later. Fans are hungry for details about what’s next. Some speculate that Nintendo is gearing up to address longstanding requests, like new entries for dormant franchises or more dramatic expansions for existing series. Others wonder if the quiet period is a deliberate move to avoid overshadowing certain mid-tier projects, giving them a chance to shine without sharing the spotlight. A quieter lineup also means the few big titles that did come out, like Super Mario Party and The Legend Of Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom, received more focused attention. That can be good news for players who want in-depth coverage, thorough updates, and a sense that each release truly matters. However, without a critical mass of showstoppers, Nintendo’s ranking inevitably took a hit when measured against competitors who might have unleashed multiple success stories within the same timeframe.

SEGA’s Surprising Achievement

In a twist that may feel like a narrative plucked straight from the console wars of yesteryear, SEGA claimed the number one spot this year. Their average score of 82.9 across 12 releases showcases a remarkable resurgence. For those who remember the days when SEGA and Nintendo were neck-and-neck rivals, this outcome has a dash of poetic irony. Critics lauded SEGA’s lineup for its variety and quality, highlighting everything from innovative indie collaborations to polished entries in beloved franchises. One could argue that SEGA capitalized on strategic timing, releasing games in genres that perhaps faced less direct competition or simply hitting a sweet spot of critical favor. Nintendo enthusiasts might raise an eyebrow at the notion of SEGA outshining the house that Mario built. However, an underdog story can be charming, and it’s a reminder that the gaming landscape is far from static. Former heavyweights can reclaim glory if they play their cards right, just as giants can stumble if they don’t keep a pulse on what resonates with audiences. Whether you view this as a triumphant comeback or a fleeting moment of fame, SEGA’s victory underscores one fundamental truth: surprises are the lifeblood of gaming. Nothing is set in stone, and a single year’s performance can reshape how we perceive the entire industry.

Spotlight On Other Publishers

Beyond Nintendo and SEGA, several other publishers found themselves in the spotlight. Capcom continued its impressive stride, thanks to well-received sequels and expansions. Its knack for revitalizing older franchises and refining new ones has earned it a stellar reputation for delivering consistent hits. Microsoft, often seen as a juggernaut in the console market, also grabbed positive attention for a carefully curated set of titles that struck a chord with both critics and players. Sony, another major player, secured a place in the top ranks by blending blockbuster experiences with select indie partnerships. Gamers on different platforms appreciated how Sony balanced big-budget exclusives and smaller creative ventures. That mix of risk-taking and reliable quality often contributes to a strong Metascore average. Smaller publishers also made their mark, with a few known for niche but innovative titles. Even if they didn’t dominate the top tiers, their presence in the list is a testament to the diversity of the modern gaming scene. People often look to these emerging publishers for genre-bending ideas that can pave the way for fresh experiences. It’s worth noting how fluid these rankings can be. A publisher that stumbles one year may soar the next, propelled by a single title that captures the gaming world’s collective attention. Conversely, consistent output across several good but not great releases might anchor a publisher somewhere in the middle. Ultimately, these charts reflect ongoing experiments, success stories, and lessons learned—a grand tapestry that captures a year in gaming.

Metascore: How It Works

Anyone who’s spent time on Metacritic knows that each game’s critic reviews are converted into a numerical scale. Metacritic then employs a proprietary weighting system, giving some outlets more influence than others based on their historical accuracy and credibility. The aggregated total forms the Metascore, which is typically represented on a 100-point scale. Publishers, in turn, see their overall ranking calculated from the average scores of all their releases in a given year. While some folks question the transparency of this weighting, it remains one of the most recognized and widely cited metrics in gaming. Many fans claim it helps cut through marketing hype to get a sense of whether a title is generally well-received. On the other hand, detractors argue that boiling down a game’s worth to a single number is simplistic. Publishers keep a close eye on these results, as they can sway media coverage and consumer interest. A game that achieves an exceptionally high Metascore tends to enjoy a longer spotlight, while a lower score can lead to critical jokes, memes, or an uphill battle in winning over players. At times, internal development teams also use feedback reflected in Metascores to adapt future projects.

Why Rankings Matter To Fans

Why do these lists capture so much attention? Part of it is the joy of seeing your favorite publisher get the praise you feel it deserves. Another part is the communal aspect—rankings provide fertile ground for heated debates, celebratory posts, and even memes. For many, it’s a form of friendly rivalry. Are you a Nintendo loyalist or a SEGA comeback champion? Do you root for underdog studios? The annual Metacritic reveal gives everyone something to latch onto. There’s also a practical angle. Gamers with limited time and budgets often gravitate toward titles with high critical acclaim, using Metascores as a preliminary filter. While it’s essential to note that your personal enjoyment might differ from a critic’s perspective, these averages can still serve as a handy rule of thumb. For publishers like Nintendo, it’s a reminder that goodwill can wane if consistently strong results aren’t maintained. Reputation alone doesn’t guarantee high rankings. Meanwhile, SEGA’s ascent demonstrates that redemption is possible, reinforcing that no publisher is stuck in one place forever. These dynamics add layers of drama to the gaming world, keeping fans eagerly awaiting each new Metacritic announcement.

Looking ahead, it appears the stage is set for fierce competition. With a new calendar year come fresh releases, rumored hardware upgrades, and unannounced projects. Nintendo’s 2024 performance might serve as a catalyst for bigger, bolder moves in 2025. Whether that means new installments in beloved series or daring collaborations remains to be seen. Industry pundits point to growing demands for cross-platform play, online functionality, and robust streaming options. Publishers that adapt to these emerging preferences will likely fare better in the coming year’s rankings. There’s also talk about branching out into augmented reality or more advanced VR, adding new dimensions to the gaming experience. That said, one year of data can only forecast so much. Trends shift quickly in this domain, often propelled by unexpected hits. A single title can introduce new mechanics or reimagine old formulas, transforming player expectations overnight. For publishers at every tier, the name of the game is adaptation. If Nintendo’s quiet year was a prelude to something grand, 2025 might bring revelations that put them back on top. It’s not just speculation—Nintendo has a pattern of surprising players with innovative hardware (like the Switch in past years) or reinvigorating established franchises in imaginative ways. Gamers, critics, and even competitors will be watching closely to see if 2024 was a mere blip or part of a larger shift.

Looking Ahead To Future Releases

As fans eagerly speculate on Nintendo’s lineup, each new rumor or trademark filing becomes a source of excitement. The gaming world thrives on anticipation, and there’s no shortage of it when it comes to seeing what Nintendo will do next. Could we get a new 3D platformer that shakes up the Mario formula? Will The Legend Of Zelda see a groundbreaking spinoff that explores uncharted territory? The possibilities are vast. It’s also worth noting that once-lower-ranked publishers have soared in subsequent years, fueled by a standout title that captivated critics. Nintendo has certainly done it before, and chances are strong they can do it again. In the meantime, fans can still savor the existing 2024 releases, celebrating the intricate charm of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door or the party-centric fun of Super Mario Party. Looking beyond Nintendo, the landscape remains dynamic. SEGA’s achievement isn’t guaranteed to hold unless they maintain their momentum. Capcom, Sony, Microsoft, and other big names are all vying to produce the next masterpiece that resonates universally. The competitive spirit among these titans ultimately benefits gamers, driving the industry forward and sparking innovations that might not arise in a less competitive environment. In short, 2024’s rankings are but one page in the ever-evolving chronicle of gaming history. If there’s one constant to rely on, it’s that nothing stays the same for long. Publishers once overshadowed by the big players can leapfrog to the front with a timely hit. Likewise, legendary names can slip if they let their guard down. That unpredictability is part of what keeps gaming so endlessly fascinating.

Conclusion

Nintendo’s 2024 Metacritic result might have caught some fans off guard, but it doesn’t mark the end of an era. Instead, it’s an invitation to reflect, adapt, and push for greater heights. Even at 22nd place, the publisher maintains a “Generally Favorable” average—a sign that, while there’s room for growth, the foundation remains strong. SEGA’s triumph, meanwhile, spotlights how publishers long considered underdogs can roar back into relevance. For gamers, the real takeaway is the variety and surprises that each year brings. Metacritic rankings offer a snapshot of industry currents but don’t capture every nuance or personal experience. Whether you’re still soaking up last year’s releases or eagerly scouting the horizon for new ones, remember that the joy of gaming transcends any list. Nintendo’s story continues to unfold, and future chapters may bring the kind of groundbreaking innovation the company has been known for all along.

FAQs
  • Q: Why did Nintendo rank so low compared to previous years?
    • A: Many believe fewer standout releases and a quieter lineup contributed to the drop, though the average score was still considered decent.
  • Q: Did Nintendo release any highly rated games in 2024?
    • A: Yes. While the overall average fell short of earlier years, titles like the Paper Mario remake and The Legend Of Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom still earned praise.
  • Q: How did SEGA manage to take the top spot?
    • A: SEGA launched a strong roster of games that scored highly with critics, showcasing variety and quality across several genres.
  • Q: Are these Metacritic rankings a definitive measure of a game’s quality?
    • A: They’re influential but not absolute. Metascores aggregate critic reviews, but personal taste can differ significantly from overall averages.
  • Q: What should we expect from Nintendo in the future?
    • A: Although nothing is confirmed, there’s widespread anticipation for new game announcements and possibly more ambitious projects, given Nintendo’s history of innovation.
Sources
WhatsAppMessengerLinkedInRedditPinterestBufferSMS